Last night on America’s Next Top Model the girls had to pose as mermaids — our favorite! Would they ruin our dream trend for the world? Well, not quite. The judges were positively thrilled with the results of the girls lying down wearing jewelry and lipstick with illustrated lobsters clawing at their hair in the background. “You can do so many different things,” Tyra tells one girl who gets a good picture. Like … stand up and lie down? The mouth on another girl had André Leon Talley in fits. “I think the lips, I would want to eat them for breakfast as toast,” he enthuses. See more highlights from reality television’s best judge ever in the video.