I’ve never been a big believer in one-size-fits-all or one-color-fits-all. Maybe one-color-suits-most. But if there was such a thing as a universally flattering shade, plum would be a contender. Looking for their favorite tonal blends of pink, purple, and brown (depending on how nineties they wanted to go), the Cut staff perused the beauty closet to find their favorite shades from fall’s cornucopia of plummy hues. Click through the slideshow for their magenta, wine-stained, fuchsia, and berry-lipped favorites. There’s something for everyone.