• Intelligencer
  • The Cut
  • Vulture
  • The Strategist
  • Curbed
  • Grub Street
  • Subscribe to the Magazine Give a Gift Subscription Buy Back Issues Current Issue Contents
    Subscribe to New York Magazine
  • Subscribe
  • Profile
    Sign Out
The Cut
  • Style
  • Self
  • Culture
  • Power
Style
  • Fashion
  • Beauty
  • Shopping
  • Design Hunting
  • New York Weddings
  • Parties & Red Carpet
  • Fashion Shows
  • Cathy Horyn
Self
  • Health & Wellness
  • Motherhood
  • Advice
  • Sex & Relationships
  • Science of Us
  • Horoscopes
  • Ask Polly
Culture
  • Books
  • Television
  • Movies
  • Music
  • Celebrity
Power
  • Politics
  • Work
  • Money
  • Rebecca Traister
More
  • Latest Stories
  • Video
  • About Us
  • The Cut Shop
  • nymag.com
  • New York Magazine
  • Intelligencer
  • Vulture
  • The Cut
  • The Strategist
  • Grub Street
smell you later
October 22, 2014

A Fragrance Critic on the Problem With Perfume

By Kathleen Hou

Share

  • Share
  • Tweet
Photo: Courtesy of Dior

From 2006 to 2010, writer Chandler Burr served as the New York Times’ first (and only) perfume critic. He famously awarded four stars and the rating of “excellent” to Britney Spears’s Midnight Fantasy, calling it “the perfect olfactory incarnation of Spears (on the screen, not behind the wheel of a car).” Now he is the author of the new book Dior: The Perfumes, which incorporates Burr’s critique with vintage images of Dior perfume iconography. Here, he talks to the Cut about why fragrance and art is a lie, and why he wants to deliver a fuck-you to the fragrance industry. Read his interview below and click through the slideshow for vintage images of Dior in his atelier and more from the book.

You’re the author of a new book about Dior perfumes, so it’s a bit surprising that you’re known for hating perfume marketing copy.
Dior
a
pproached my agent and I initially turned the project down because I assumed what they wanted was marketing copy. I said, “I’m absolutely not interested in this at all.” And my agent called me back laughing and said, “They loved the fact you turned it down. What they want is independent voice and someone who is not part of Dior. They want you contextualize Dior’s work in scent art within the context of art history.”

Dior said, “We’re not asking you to write about anything you don’t like, that is your freedom.” For example, I didn’t want to write about Higher Energy, a very commercial perfume, which they commissioned. We went through to choose which ones to write about and there are also three essays on Dior’s life, the role of gardens in his life, and on perfume, in general.

What makes perfume an art?
All
art must lie by definition, but in the best possible sense. All art must be artificial because the artist is seeking to manipulate the viewer or listener. For example, when you read a novel, it’s something that is utterly false. It’s made-up constructions invented by the authors; every word in them is a lie. As Picasso said, “Art is the lie that tells the truth.”

So where does the truth lie in perfume?
T
here is a truth that the artist has. That truth, that vision, is what he or she seeks to convey to the audience. The degree to which the lie convinces you, forces you to see the world from their perspective. The more the work of art manipulates you, the better it is.

When did you realize that perfume was an art?
While waiting for my Eurostar to London in the Gare du Nord in Paris, I
met this guy, who was a biophysicist and genius on perfume. We had a long conversation about a scientific theory and I started writing a book about him. It was only about two to three months in that I realized it was going to be a book about perfume. His love of perfume informed his scientific work in every single way.

David Remnick got the book from my agent and asked me to write a piece about the creation of a perfume. I said I didn’t want to do it because I wasn’t a perfumer. I also dislike the fashion industry intensely. There is no link between fashion and perfume.

You don’t think there is a link between fashion and perfume? That is a bold statement coming from the author of a book about Dior.
I
t’s a modern anomaly that we associate fashion with perfume. Scents have always been made by perfumers. For example, it was always done by Guerlain with a perfumer. It would never have occurred to [Guerlain] in a million years to make dresses.

You hate perfume marketing copy, but let’s say you were creating your own perfume: How would you market it?
Here’s the problem, you have a serious treatment of films, including popular ones. But nobody applies serious language or thought or conceits to perfume. In commercial marketing, the perfume will be described as saying, for example, notes of caramel. No one has an essence of caramel; it doesn’t exist. Or it will say notes of moon rock or of ammonium thioglycolic. And my answer to that is, “Fuck you, if you are going to be serious about that!” But they are not serious about that! And no one is.

But let’s put this as an analogy. There’s a wonderful painter named Ed Ruscha. He paints, the gallerist then exhibits it in a commercial space. He shows it to the critics and the public and the critics write about it or collectors come look at it and purchase it. If I ever do create or direct a scent, I would market it by talking about the artist. Frédéric Malle conceived and presents his collection this way, and it’s by a mile the most legitimate and interesting–to my mind–way to do it. I would be the gallerist, but I would talk about the work itself not in terms of me or the perfumer. I would talk about it in terms of its aesthetic effect. I would create it as something serious, which is what it should be treated as.

But how would you understand what a scent smells like without describing the notes?
Using notes is
an incredibly impoverished way of “understanding what a scent smells like.” It is the equivalent of understanding a painting by…

By saying it has lots of reds and blues?
E
xactly. Or what a musical work sounds like by saying “D minor.” It doesn’t tell you anything about the work. Thom Yorke can write in D minor. And so can Beethoven. And you will have two completely different works of art.

This interview has been condensed and edited.

Related

Q&A: Hermès’s Perfumers on Luxury, Perfume Bloggers, and Nighttime Scents
View
1 / 15 Photos
“Canework” coat, Spring-Summer 1991 Prêt-à-Porter collection. Collection Christian Dior Photo: Courtesy of Dior
House of Dior models arriving in Australia, 1957. Collection Christian Dior Parfums Photo: Courtesy of Dior
This black-and-white photograph by Dominique Issermann was an iconic Eau Sauvage image © Eau Sauvage advertisement campaign, photo Dominique Isse... This black-and-white photograph by Dominique Issermann was an iconic Eau Sauvage image © Eau Sauvage advertisement campaign, photo Dominique Issermann Photo: Courtesy of Dior
The first Dune advertisement, 1991. Photograph by Dominique Issermann © Dune advertisement campaign, photo Dominique Issermann Photo: Courtesy of... The first Dune advertisement, 1991. Photograph by Dominique Issermann © Dune advertisement campaign, photo Dominique Issermann Photo: Courtesy of Dior
Diorling evening dress, Spring-Summer 1963 Haute Couture collection. Collection Christian Dior Parfums Photo: Courtesy of Dior
Miss Dior, short evening gown embroidered with a thousand flowers, Spring-Summer 1949 Haute Couture collection © Laziz Hamani Photo: Courtesy of ... Miss Dior, short evening gown embroidered with a thousand flowers, Spring-Summer 1949 Haute Couture collection © Laziz Hamani Photo: Courtesy of Dior
Novembre ensemble, Autumn-Winter 1955 Haute Couture collection. Photograph by Mike de Dulmen Photo: Courtesy of Dior
Advertising image for Poison, 1985. Photograph by Tyen © Tyen Photo: Courtesy of Dior
Canework design hat, Spring-Summer 1991 Prêt-à-Porter collection. Collection Christian Dior Photo: Courtesy of Dior
Press photograph, 1972. Collection Christian Dior Parfums Photo: Courtesy of Dior
Origami pleating for the Spring-Summer 2007 Haute Couture collection © Laziz Hamani 3 - Photo: Courtesy of Dior
From the En 8 line to J’adore, the line as it was created by the couturier is at the heart of all Dior creations. Collection Christian Dior Parfums P... From the En 8 line to J’adore, the line as it was created by the couturier is at the heart of all Dior creations. Collection Christian Dior Parfums Photo: Courtesy of Dior
Detail of the Fahrenheit bottle, 2008 © Philippe Schlienger Photo: Philippe Schlienger 33(0)6 16 44 15 33 philtenger@yahoo.fr
© Philippe Schlienger Photo: Courtesy of Dior
Photo: Courtesy of Dior
1 / 15

Tags:

  • beauty
  • chandler burr
  • parfums christian dior
  • scent
  • fragrance
  • perfume
  • christian dior
  • dior
  • perfume critic
  • smell you later
  • More

More Galleries

in memoriam Dec. 30, 2020
30 Incredible Fashion Moments From Pierre Cardin  Remembering a creative visionary. 
By Andrew Nguyen
rest in power Dec. 23, 2020
A Photo Memorial for an Iconic Model  She passed away suddenly at the age of 50 this week. 
campaign trail Nov. 18, 2020
‘Tis the Season for New Fashion Ads  See the best ones from Gucci, Prada, Versace, and more. 
By Emily Burns
nyfw spring 2021 Oct. 26, 2020
How a Great Collection Comes Alive  Christopher John Rogers launched its first-ever online shop, along with a new campaign. 
By Andrew Nguyen
campaign trail Sept. 24, 2020
See the Fashion Campaigns for Fall 2020  From Prada, Michael Kors, Celine, Louis Vuitton, and more. 
By Andrew Nguyen
nyfw spring 2021 Sept. 22, 2020
See the Coach Spring 2021 Collection  Worn by Megan Thee Stallion, Kate Moss, Cole Sprouse, and more. 
By Andrew Nguyen
fashion Sept. 16, 2020
The Stunning Awkwardness of Face Masks on the Red Carpet  Celebrities tried to make the best of a strange situation at the 2020 Venice Film Festival. 
one word one shot Sept. 15, 2020
72 Designers on Their Spring/Summer Inspirations  Just in time for Fashion Week. 
By the Cut
red carpet Sept. 8, 2020
This Red Carpet Was Totally Surreal  But also amazing. See all the looks at the Venice Film Festival. 
By Emilia Petrarca and Andrew Nguyen
in memoriam Aug. 31, 2020
Remembering Chadwick Boseman on the Red Carpet  His style was bold, risk-taking, and always impeccable. 
the wedding files Aug. 21, 2020
The Design-Minded Couple Who Didn’t Want to Try Too Hard  The bride got a wonderful surprise the morning of her wedding. 
By Kaitlin Menza
the wedding files Aug. 14, 2020
A Costa Rica Wedding During the Rainy Season  Thunder roared during the toasts. 
By Kaitlin Menza
the wedding files Aug. 7, 2020
A San Francisco Wedding at a Big, Empty Pier  The bride changed into crushed-velvet pants for the disco-infused reception. 
By Kaitlin Menza
the wedding files July 31, 2020
An Elopement Among the Lupines in Iceland  The late afternoon was spent snapping photos near waterfalls and black beaches. 
By Kaitlin Menza
the wedding files July 24, 2020
A Pennsylvania Potluck for 280 People  “I looked at her for the first time and had this feeling like, You. I know you.” 
By Kaitlin Menza
milan fashion week July 22, 2020
Behind the Scenes at Gucci’s Virtual Show  Instead of models, members of the design team sported the eccentric collection. 
By Andrew Nguyen
the wedding files July 17, 2020
A Dance Party Under Puerto Rican Palm Trees  Bad Bunny blasted and pitorro flowed. 
By Kaitlin Menza
the wedding files July 10, 2020
A Zoom Wedding Only Two Digital Creatives Could Produce  The couple coordinated multiple video segments, breakout rooms, and a dance party. 
By Kaitlin Menza
the wedding files July 3, 2020
The Anti-Spectacle Wedding That Turned Into a Spectacle  Brooklyn Bridge Park was the site of their first date, proposal, and wedding. 
By Kaitlin Menza
the wedding files June 26, 2020
A Night at the Philadelphia Museum of Art  The flowers were specially treated to protect the masterpieces. 
By Kaitlin Menza
  • Style
  • Self
  • Culture
  • Power
  • Newsletters
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Help
  • We’re Hiring
  • Press
  • Trademark
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Ad Choices
  • Do Not Sell My Info
The Cut is a Vox Media Network. © 2021 Vox Media, LLC. All rights reserved.